EXAMINING
THE BIBLICAL EVIDENCE
(The Apostle Peter's 1st Epistle)
by Al Maxey
Among all the "catholic," or "minor," epistles none has been more widely used
or more highly respected during the history of the church than the first epistle
attributed to the apostle Peter. None of the early church Fathers
challenged the authenticity of this particular work, and nearly all quoted from
it extensively. The most probable date for the composition of this letter is
64 A.D., just a year prior to Peter's execution in Rome. It was addressed "to
those who reside as aliens, scattered throughout Pontus, Galatia, Cappadocia,
Asia, and Bithynia." The majority of scholars believe it was written from the
city of Rome. It is an epistle of hope in the face of persecution and suffering,
and a testimony to the power of a Christ-like life to impact those living in darkness.
One scholar wrote, "Here is the application of Jesus' teaching that
His followers are the salt of the earth and the light of the world."
I Peter 5:1-4
With regard to the topic of elders, Peter, who was not only an apostle
and evangelist but also an elder (I Peter 5:1), makes several observations in
a passage near the end of this epistle.
#1 --- "Shepherd the flock of God among you."
It should be noted that the flock is God's; it does not belong to the
elders. They are merely God's caretakers; trustees of that which belongs to
another; watchmen who must one day give an account. The NIV reads, "Be
shepherds of God's flock that is under your care." It is also vital to note that
the sheep are among the elders, and thus the shepherds are
among the sheep. There is no idea of superiority or separation. The Greek
word for "shepherd" is poimaino, which means "to shepherd; to
perform the duties of a shepherd; to feed, pasture, tend, direct, and care for a
flock." This word is used only twice with reference to elders (here and Acts 20:28).
#2 --- "Serving as overseers" (NIV). This is the Greek word
episkopeo, which means "to look at; to see to something; to care
for; to oversee." The NASB reads, "exercising oversight." The KJV has, "taking
the oversight thereof." Although most translations include this phrase, there is
nevertheless some doubt as to whether this word was actually a part of the
original text (see: Bruce M. Metzger, A Textual Commentary on the Greek
New Testament, p. 695-696). This word appears only one other time in
the New Testament writings: "See to it that no one comes short of the
grace of God; that no root of bitterness springing up causes trouble" (Hebrews
12:15). An elder, thus, is a person who sees to the spiritual, and
sometimes material, affairs of the flock of God.
#3 --- Elders are to serve "not under compulsion, but voluntarily."
These are two Greek adverbs which are opposites. They speak of that which is
done unwillingly and willingly. A man who serves as an elder must do so willingly;
he must have a desire to serve (I Timothy 3:1). Peter continues by
saying not only must the spiritual leader of the flock provide willing
service, but he must do so "with eagerness!" This is also an adverb, and it
means "promptly, readily, heartily, cheerfully, eagerly."
#4 --- Elders are not to serve for the sake of "sordid gain"
(NASB). Other translations are: "Not greedy for money" (NIV). "Not for shameful
gain" (RSV). "Not for shameful profit" (NAB, St. Joseph edition). "Not for what
you will get out of it" (LB). The elder does not accept this position of service
in the Body of Christ because he hopes to personally profit from it (in the sense
of worldly gain: Fame, fortune, power, etc.).
#5 --- "Not lording it over those entrusted to you"
(NIV). "Nor yet as lording it over those allotted to your charge" (NASB). "Neither
as being lords over God's heritage" (KJV). "Not as domineering over those in
your charge" (RSV). "Not tyrannizing over those who are allotted to your care"
(NEB). "Don't be tyrants!" (LB).
This is the Greek word katakurieuo, which is a combination of two
words: The word for "lord" and a preposition meaning "down upon; down from."
When joined together they convey the meaning, "to lord it down upon; to bring
under one's power; to master, overcome, or domineer another." This is something
which elders are not to do. God's spiritual leaders are among
the flock as fellow sheep and servants, before the flock as guides
and examples, but never above the flock in the sense of a master or
tyrant. This word appears only 4 times within the pages of the New Covenant
writings, 3 of which have to do with leadership, and in each case it is condemned!
--- twice by Jesus Himself, who says that His leaders must not be little lords!!
(Read: Matthew 20:20-28; Mark 10:35-45) --- The other occurrence of this word
is Acts 19:16. Some scholars feel Diotrephes (III John 9-10) may have been a
"tyrannical elder." (NOTE: Even Paul, as an apostle, did not feel he had the
right to act as a "lord" over God's flock: "Not that we lord it over
your faith, but we are workers with you for your joy" -- II Corinthians
1:24).
#6 --- "Being examples to the flock." This is
the Greek word tupos, which means "to make an impression upon;
a pattern, mold, or model from which something is made or fashioned." Once
again we see that elders lead by the influence of the example or pattern or model
of their godly lives. Their lives make an impression on others.
In vs. 4 Peter looks forward to the 2nd coming of Christ Jesus, and he makes a
promise to those elders who have served the flock well: "And when the Chief
Shepherd appears, you will receive the crown of glory that will never fade away."
Jesus, God's unique Son, is the "Shepherd and Guardian" of our souls (I Peter
2:25). If one truly desires to learn how best to serve as a shepherd/elder of the
flock, he should look to Jesus and His example! "He is the supreme
Shepherd of the flock, all others are undershepherds, who must learn
their shepherding from Him" (R.C.H. Lenski, The Interpretation of the
Epistles of St. Peter, p. 220). (NOTE: For an excellent discussion of both
good and bad shepherds, read Ezekiel 34.)
"Like a shepherd He will tend His flock,
"I will feed My flock
after My own heart,
who will feed you on knowledge and understanding."
Jeremiah 3:15
in His arm He will gather the lambs,
and carry them in His bosom;
He will gently lead the nursing ewes."
Isaiah 40:11
and I will lead them to rest,"
declares the Lord God.
"I will seek the lost, bring back the scattered,
bind up the broken, and strengthen the sick."
Ezekiel 34:15-16
Elders Files