J. B. Geniesse

Sep 1889-Mar 1891

Vicariate of Arizona

J. Monfort

Apr 1891-Jul 1897

P. Laisaigne

Oct 1897-Jan 1898

C. Duran

Feb 1898-Nov 1898

A. Albrecht

Dec 1898-Aug 1899

J. Bezamat

Sep 1899-Oct 1899

Cyprian Vabre

Nov 1899-Nov 1900

Seat of Parish transferred to Hillsboro Dec 8 1909

Peter J. Immel

Dec 1900-Feb 1903

Seat returned to Rodey Feb 1902

Andres Echallier

Mar 1903-Jun 1912

Diocese of El Paso 1915

Marius Gerey

Feb 1912-Apr 1916

R. Vershaffelt

Apr 1916-Mar 1917

Gregorio Farias

Mar 1917-Sep 1917

A. Marin

Aug 1917-Dec 1919

Gregorio Farias

May 1919-Nov 1920

Max Weyers

Apr 1920-Nov 1920

Carlos Martinez

Jan 1921-Apr 1921

Domingo Ledesma

Apr 1921-Aug 1929

Michael Estivill

Aug 1929-Oct 1937

Ramon Estivill

Mar 1937-Jun 1940

James Canyellas

Jun 1940-Sep 1941

Garfield made Parish in 1939

Frank Basile

Sep 1941-Apr 1948

Felix Caminos

May 1948-Jul 1949

Gabriel Lopez

Jul 1949-Feb 1950

Stanley Aleksiejus

Mar 1950-Jul 1955

Justin Klumbis

Jul 1955-Jun 1968

Parish Seat transferred to Hatch in 1963

Arthur C. M. Morgan

Jun 1968-Oct 1973

Jacob Joerger, O.P.

Oct 1973-Oct 1977

Aloys Kettler

Nov 1977-Sep 1985

Diocese of Las Cruces Oct 1982

R. E. Power

Oct 1985-Jul 1988

Miguel Macaya

Jul 1988-Sep 1990

R. E. Power

Oct 1990-Dec 1991

Benito Suen

Jan 1992-Jul 1993

R. E. Power

Aug 1993-Feb 1994

Bill McCann

Feb 1994-Jun 2001