I spent three days at Bozrah. There is much to be
seen there, - much of Scriptural, and still more of historical and
antiquarian interest; and I tried to see it all. Bozrah was a strong
city, as its name implies -
Bozrah, "fortress," - and a
magnificent city; and numerous vestiges of its ancient strength and
magnificence remain to this day. Its ruins are nearly five miles in
circuit; its walls are lofty and
massive; and
its castle is one of the largest and strongest fortresses in Syria.
Among the ruins I saw two theatres, six temples, and ten or twelve
churches and mosques; besides palaces, baths, fountains, aqueducts,
triumphal arches, and other structures almost without number. The old
Bozrites must have been men of great taste and enterprise as well as
wealth. Some of the buildings I saw there would grace the proudest
capital of modern Europe.
It was a work of no little toil to explore
Bozrah. The streets are mostly covered, and in some places completely
blocked up, with fallen buildings and heaps of rubbish. Over these I
had to climb, risking my limbs among loose
stones.
The principal structures, too, are so much encumbered with broken
columns and the piled-up ruins of roofs and pediments, that one has
great difficulty in getting at them, and discovering their points of
interest or beauty. In trying to copy a Greek inscription over the door
of a church, I clambered to the top of a wall. My weight caused it to
topple over, and it fell with a terrible crash. It was only by a sudden
and hazardous leap I escaped, and barely escaped, being buried beneath
it. And we were hourly exposed to danger of another and still more
pressing kind. Bozrah had once a population of a hundred thousand souls
and more; when I was there its whole inhabitants comprised just
twenty families!
These live huddled together in the lower stories of some very ancient
houses near the castle. The rest of the city is completely desolate.
The fountains near the city, and the rich pastures which encircle them,
attract wandering Bedawîn, - outcasts from the larger tribes, and
notorious thieves and brigands. These come up from the desert with a
few goats, sheep, and donkeys, and perhaps a horse; and they lurk,
gipsy-like, about the fountains and among the ruins of the large
outlying towns of
Bashan, watching every opportunity to plunder an unguarded caravan or
strip
(Luke 10:30) an unwary traveller, or steal a stray camel. The whole
environs of Bozrah are infested with them, owing to the extent of the
ruins and the numbers of wells and springs in and around them. Our
arrival, numbers, and equipments had been carefully noted; and armed
men lay in wait, as we soon discovered, at various places, in the hope
of entrapping and plundering some straggler. Once, indeed, a bold
attempt was made by their combined forces to carry off our whole party.
We had fortunately taken the precaution on our arrival to engage the
brother of the sheikh as guide and guard during our stay; and to this
arrangement, joined to the fear of the Druse escort, we owed our
safety. So true has time made the words of Jeremiah: "
The spoilers are come upon all high places through the wilderness ... no flesh shall have peace" (Jer. 12:12). The words of Ezekiel, too, are strikingly applicable to the present state of Bozrah: "
Thus
saith the Lord God of the land of Israel, They shall eat their bread
with carefulness, and drink their water with astonishment, that her
land may be desolate from all that is therein, because of the violence
of all them that dwell therein. And the cities that are inhabited shall
be laid waste, and the land shall be desolate" (Ezek. 12:19, 20).
The sheikh of Bozrah told me that his flocks
would not be safe even in his own court-yard at night, and that armed
sentinels had to patrol continually round their little fields at
harvest-time. "If it were not for the castle," he said, "which has high
walls, and a strong iron gate, we should be forced to leave Busrah
altogether. We could not stay here a week. The Bedawîn swarm round the
ruins. They steal everything they can lay hold of, - goat, sheep, cow,
horse, or camel; and before we can get on their track they are far away
in the desert."
Two or three incidents came under my own notice
which proved the truth of the sheikh’s sad statement. One day when
examining the ruins of a large mosque, the head of a Bedawy appeared
over an adjoining wall, looking at us. The sheikh, who was by my side,
cried out, on seeing him, "Dog, you stole my sheep!" and seizing a
stone
he hurled it at him with such force and precision as must have brained
him had he not ducked behind the wall. The sheikh and his companions
gave chase, but the fellow escaped. One cannot but compare such scenes,
scenes of ordinary life, of everyday occurrence in
Bashan, with the language of prophecy: "
I will give it (the land of Israel)
into
the hands of the strangers for a prey, and to the wicked of the earth
for a spoil; ... robbers shall enter into it and defile it ... The land
is full of bloody crimes, and the city is full of violence" (Ezek. 7:2, 21-23).
Bozrah was one of the strongest cities of
Bashan;
it was, indeed, the most celebrated fortress east of the Jordan, during
the Roman rule in Syria. Some parts of its wall are still almost
perfect, a
massive rampart of solid masonry,
fifteen feet thick and nearly thirty high, with great square towers at
intervals. The walled city was almost a rectangle, about a mile and a
quarter long by a mile broad; and outside this were large straggling
suburbs. A straight street intersects the city lengthwise, and has a
beautiful gate at each end; and other straight streets run across it
Roman Bozrah (or
Bostra) was a beautiful city, with long
straight avenues and spacious thoroughfares; but the Saracens built
their miserable little shops and quaint irregular houses along the
sides of the streets, out and in, here and there, as fancy or funds
directed; and they thus converted the stately Roman capital, as they
did Damascus and, Antioch, into a labyrinth of narrow, crooked, gloomy
lanes. One sees the splendid, Roman palace, and gorgeous Greek temple,
and shapeless Arab
dukkân, side by side, alike in ruins, just as if the words of Isaiah had been written with special reference to this City of
Moab: "
He
shall bring down their pride together with the spoil of their hands.
And the fortress of the high fort of thy walls shall He bring down, lay
low, and bring to the ground, even to the dust" (Isa. 15:11, 12).
It might perhaps be as trying to my reader’s
patience as it was to my limbs, were I to retrace with him all my
wanderings among the ruins of Bozrah; relating every little incident
and adventure; and describing the wonders of art and architecture, and
the curiosities of votive tablet, and dedicatory inscription on altar,
tomb, church, and temple, which I examined and deciphered during these
three days. Still I think many will wish to hear a few particulars
about an old Bible city, and a city of so much historical importance in
the latter days of
Bashan’s glory. To me and to
my companions it was intensely interesting to note the changes that old
city has undergone. They are shown in the strata of its ruins just as
geological periods are shown in the strata of the earth’s crust. Some
of them are recorded, too, on monumental tablets, containing the
legends of other centuries. In one spot, deep down beneath the
accumulated remains of more recent buildings, I saw the simple,
massive, primitive dwellings of the aborigines, with their
stone doors and
stone roofs. These were built and inhabited by the gigantic
Emim and
Rephaim
long before the Chaldean shepherd migrated from Ur to Canaan (Gen.
14:5). High above them rose the classic portico of a Roman temple,
shattered and tottering, but still grand in its ruins. Passing between
the columns, I saw over its beautifully sculptured doorway a Greek
inscription, telling how, in the fourth century, the temple became a
church, and was dedicated to St. John. On entering the building, the
record of still another change appeared on the cracked plaster of the
walls. Upon it was traced in huge Arabic characters the well-known
motto of Islamism: - "
There is no God but God, and Mohammed is the prophet of God."
One of the first buildings I visited was the
castle, and on my way to it I passed a triumphal arch, erected, as a
Latin inscription tells us, in honour of Julius, prefect of the first
Parthian Philippine legion. It was most likely built during the reign
of the emperor Philip, who was a native of Bozrah. The castle stands on
the south side of the city, without the walls; and forming a separate
fortress, was fitted at once to defend and command the town. It is of
great size and strength, and the outer walls, towers, gate, and moat
are nearly perfect; but the interior is ruinous. On the basement are
immense vaulted tanks, stores, and galleries; and over them were
chambers sufficient to accommodate a small army. In the very centre of
the structure, supported on
massive piers and
arches, are the remains of a theatre. This splendid monument of the
luxury and magnificence of former days was so designed that the
spectators commanded a view of the city and the whole plain beyond it
to the base of Hermon. The building is a semicircle, 270 feet in
diameter, and open above, like all Roman theatres. It was no doubt
intended for the amusement of the Roman garrison, when Bostra was the
capital of a province and the headquarters of a legion.
*
The
keep is a huge square tower, rising high above the battlements, and overlooking the plains of
Bashan and
Moab.
From it I saw that Bozrah was in ancient times connected by a series of
great highways with the leading cities and districts in
Bashan
and Arabia. They diverge from the city in straight lines; and my eye
followed one after another till it disappeared in the far distance. One
ran westward to the town of Ghusam, and then to
Edrei; another northward to Suweideh and Damascus; another north-west, up among the mountains of
Bashan; another to
Kerioth;
and another eastward, straight as an arrow, to the castle of Salcah,
which crowned a conical hill on the horizon. Towns and villages
appeared in every direction, thickly dotting the vast plain; a few of
those to the north are inhabited, but all those southward have been
deserted for centuries. I examined them long and carefully with my
telescope, and their walls and houses appeared to be in even better
preservation than those I had already visited. This has since been
found to be the case, for my friend Mr. Cyril Graham visited them,
penetrating this wild and dangerous country as far as Um el Jemâl, the
Beth-gamul of Scripture, which I saw from Bozrah, and to which I called
his special attention. Beth-gamul is unquestionably one of the most
remarkable places east of the Jordan. It is as large as Bozrah. It is
surrounded by high walls, and contains many
massive houses built of huge blocks of
basalt;
their roofs and doors, and even the gates of the city, being formed of
the same material. Though deserted for many centuries, the houses,
streets, walls, and gates are in as perfect preservation as if the city
had been inhabited until within the last few years. It is curious to
note the change that has taken place in the name. What the Hebrews
called "
The house of the camel," the Arabs now call "
The mother of the camel."
I cannot tell how deeply I was impressed when
looking out over that noble plain, rivalling in richness of soil the
best of England’s counties, thickly studded with cities, towns, and
villages, intersected with roads, having one of the finest climates in
the world; and yet utterly deserted, literally "
without man, without inhabitant, and without beast"
(Isa. 33:10). I cannot tell with what mingled feelings of sorrow and of
joy, of mourning and of thanksgiving, of fear and of faith, I reflected
on the history of that land; and taking out my Bible compared its
existing state, as seen with my own eyes, with the numerous predictions
regarding it written by the Hebrew prophets. In their day it was
populous and prosperous; the fields-waved with corn; the hill-sides
were covered with flocks and herds; the highways were thronged with
wayfarers; the cities resounded with the continuous din of a busy
population. And yet they wrote as if they had seen the land as I saw it
from the ramparts of Bozrah. The Spirit of the omniscient God alone
could have guided the hand that penned such predictions as these: "Then
said I, Lord, how long? And he answered,
Until the cities be
wasted without inhabitant, and the houses without man, and the land be
utterly desolate, and the Lord hath removed men far away, and there be
a great forsaking in the midst of the land" (Isa. 6:11, 12). "
The
destroyer of the Gentiles is on his way; he is gone forth from his
place to make thy land desolate; and thy cities shall be laid waste
without an inhabitant" (Jer. 4:7).
In former times a garrison was maintained in the
castle of Bozrah by the Pasha of Damascus, for the purpose of defending
the southern sections of
Bashan from the
periodical incursions of the Bedawîn. It has been withdrawn for many
years. The "Destroyer of the Gentiles" can now come up unrestrained,
"the spoilers" can now "come upon all high places through the
wilderness," the sword now" devours from the one end of the land even
to the other end of the land" (Jer. 12:12); the cities
are "without inhabitant," the houses
are "without man," the land
is "utterly desolate," judgment
has come upon it all far and near; in a word, THE WHOLE OF
BASHAN AND
MOAB IS ONE GREAT FULFILLED PROPHECY.
We were conducted by our intelligent guide to a
large church, apparently the ancient cathedral of Bozrah. It is built
in the form of a Greek cross, and on the walls of the chancel are some
remains of rude frescos, representing saints and angels. Over the door
is an inscription stating that the church was founded "by Julianus,
archbishop of Bostra, in the year A.D. 513, in honour of the blessed
martyrs Sergius, Bacchus, and Leontius." Our guide called the building
"the church of the monk Bohira;" and a very old tradition represents
this monk as playing an important part in the early history of
Mohammedanism. It is said he was a native of this city, and that, being
expelled from his convent, he joined the Arabian prophet, and aided in
writing the Koran, supplying all those stories from the Bible, the
Talmud, and the spurious Gospels, which make up so large a part of that
remarkable book.
Not far from the church is the principal mosque,
built, it is said, by the Khalif Omar. The roof was supported on
colonnades, like the early basilicas; and seventeen of the columns are
monoliths of white marble, of great beauty. Two of them have
inscriptions showing that they formerly belonged to some church, but
probably they were originally intended to ornament a Greek temple.
We extended our walk one day to the suburbs on
the north and west, where there are remains of some large and splendid
buildings. We then proceeded to the west gate, at the end of the main
street. The ancient pavement of the street, and of the road which runs
across the plain to Ghusam, is quite perfect, - not a
stone
out of place. The gate has a single but spacious Roman arch, ornamented
with pilasters and niches. Outside is a guard-house of the same style
and period. Sitting down on the broken wall of this little building, I
gazed long on the ruins of the city, and on the vast deserted plain. My
companions had taken shelter from a shower in a vacant niche; and now
there was not a human being, there was not a sign of life, within the
range of vision. The open gate revealed heaps of rubbish, and piles of
stones,
and shattered walls. In the distance a solitary column stood here. and
there, and the triumphal arch which rose over all around it, appeared
as if built to celebrate the triumph of DESOLATION. The desolation of
the plain without was as complete as that of the city within. Never
before had I seen such a picture of utter, terrible desolation, except
at Palmyra; and even there it was not so remarkable. That "city of the
desert" might rise and flourish for a season, while the tide of
commerce was rolling past it, and while it stood a solitary oasis on
the desert highway uniting the eastern and western worlds; but on the
opening up of some other channel of communication, it might naturally
decline and fall. Bozrah is altogether different. It was situated in
the midst of a fertile plain, in the centre of a populous province. It
had abundant resources, fountains of water, an impregnable fortress.
Why should Bozrah become desolate? Who would have ventured to predict
its ruin 1 It surely was no city to grow up in a day and fade in a
night! It surely did not depend for prosperity on the changeable
channel of commerce! Something above and beyond mere natural causes and
influences must have operated here. We can only understand its strange
history when we read it in the light of prophecy. Then we can see the
impress of a mightier than: human hand. We can see that the curse of an
angry God for the sin of a rebellious people has fallen upon Bozrah, "
and upon all the cities of the land of Moab far and near" (Jer. 48:24).
Two Bozrahs are mentioned in the Bible. One was
in Edom, and is referred to in the well-known passage, "Who is this
that cometh from Edom, with dyed garments from
Bozrah?" (Isa.
63:1). Upon this ancient city judgments are pronounced in connection
with Edom and Teman, whose inhabitants dwelt "in the clefts of the
rocks," and the "heights of the hills," and made their houses "like the
nests of the eagles" (Jer. 49:7-22.) When pronouncing judgment upon
Moab, the same prophet says, "Judgment is come upon the
plain country," and he names the cities which stood in the plain, and among them are Beth-gamul,
Kerioth, and
Bozrah
(Jer. 48:21-24). Evidently these predictions cannot refer to the same
place. Another fact still more conclusively establishes the point.
After completing the sentence of
Moab, including one Bozrah, the Spirit of God adds, "Yet will I bring again the captivity of
Moab
in the latter days" (Jer. 48:47); whereas in Edom’s doom we have these
terrible words, "For I have sworn by myself, saith the Lord, that
Bozrah shall become a desolation, a reproach, a waste, and a curse; and
all the cities thereof shall be
perpetual wastes" (Jer. 49:13).
**
The plain of
Moab embraced a
large part of the plateau east of the Dead Sea and the Jordan. A short
time before the exodus the Amorites conquered the northern part of that
plain; and from them it was taken by the tribes of Reuben and Gad. It
is doubtful whether the
Moabites were ever
completely expelled. They probably retired for a time to the desert,
and when Israel’s power declined, returned to their old possessions.
The predictions of Jeremiah refer to cities once held by the
Israelites, yet in his days belonging to
Moab; hence he includes Bozrah in the land of
Moab.
Subsequently, Bozrah became the capital of a large Roman province; then
the metropolitan city of Eastern Palestine, when its primate had
thirty-three bishops under him; then it was captured by the
Mohammedans, and gradually fell to ruin. Now we can see that the
prophet’s words are fulfilled, "
Judgment has come upon Bozrah."
We had not gone more than four miles from Bozrah
when an alarm was raised. The people of Bozrah had told us, and we had
known ourselves, that though the country on our proposed route is
thickly studded with towns and villages, yet not a single human being
dwells in them. When approaching the village of Burd we saw figures
moving about. At first we thought some shepherds had taken refuge
there. with their flocks; but it very soon became apparent that the
figures were not shepherds. Considerable numbers collected on the flat
house-tops, and we could see horses led out and held beneath the walls.
They evidently saw us, and were preparing for an attack. We held a
council of war, - and resolved unanimously to go forward, and if
attacked to meet the enemy, boldly. Mahmood, after examining his gun
and pistols, and loosening his sword in its seaboard, galloped off to
reconnoiter. A horseman came out to meet him. I confess it was rather
an anxious moment, but it did not last long. A few words were spoken,
and Mahmood came back with the welcome intelligence that a little
colony of Druses had migrated to the village two days previously. They
were as much alarmed at us as we were at them. So it is always now in
this unfortunate land, where the Ishmaelite roams free - "His hand
against every man and every man’s hand against him." Every stranger is
looked upon as an enemy until he is proved to be a friend. The time and
events so graphically depicted by Jeremiah have come: "
O inhabitant of Aroer, stand by the way and espy: ask him that fleeth, and her that escapeth, and say, What is done?" (Jer. 48:19)
We rode on along the Roman road, stopping
occasionally to examine with our glasses the deserted towns away to the
right and left, and once or twice galloping to those near the road, so
as to inspect their strange
massive houses,
standing complete, but tenantless. Often and often did our eyes sweep
the open plain, and scan suspicious ruins, and peer into valleys, in
the fear or hope of discovering roving Ishmaelites. We were almost
disappointed that none appeared.
Soon after leaving Burd, we entered a rocky
district; and here, among the rocks, we found some fields where a few
Druses were ploughing, each man having his gun slung over his
shoulders, and pistols in his belt. This is surely cultivation under
difficulties. From this place until we reached Salcah, we did not see a
living creature, except a flock of partridges and a herd of gazelles.
The desert of Arabia is not more desolate than this rich and once
populous plain of
Moab.
SALCAH.
Joshua tells us that the kingdom of
Og the
giant included "
all Bashan unto Salcah"
(Josh. 13:11, 12); and the Israelites took and occupied the whole
region from Mount Hermon "unto Salcah." Salcah, the eastern frontier
city of
Bashan, was now before me; its great
old castle perched on the top of a conical hill, overlooking a
boundless plain, and the city itself spread along its sloping sides,
and reaching out into the valley below. I felt glad and thankful that I
was privileged to reach the utmost eastern border of Palestine. I had
previously explored its northern border away on the plain of Hamath and
on the heights of Lebanon, and its western border from Tripoli to
Joppa; and since that time I have traversed the southern border from
Gaza eastward.
Salcah is one of the most remarkable cities in Palestine. It has been long deserted; and yet, as nearly as I could estimate,
five hundred of its houses are still standing, and from three to four hundred families might settle in it at any moment without laying a
stone,
or expending an hour’s labour on repairs. The circumference of the town
and castle together is about three miles. Besides the castle, a number
of square towers, like the belfries of churches, and a few mosques,
appear to be the only public buildings.
On approaching Salcah, we rode through an old
cemetery, and then, passing the ruins of an ancient gate, entered the
streets of the deserted city. The open doors, the empty houses, the
rank grass and weeds, the long straggling brambles in the door-ways and
windows, formed a strange, impressive picture which can never leave my
memory. Street after street we traversed, the tread of our horses
awakening mournful echoes, and startling the foxes from their dens in
the palaces of Salcah. Reaching an open paved area, in front of the
principal mosque, we committed our horses to the keeping of Mahmood,
who tied them up, unstrung his gun, and sat down to act the part of
sentry, while we explored the city.
The
castle occupies the summit of a
steep conical hill, which rises to the height of some three hundred
feet, and is the southern point of the mountain range of
Bashan.
Round the base of the hill is a deep moat, and, another still deeper
encircles the walls of the fortress. The building is a patch-work of
various periods and nations. The foundations are Jewish, if not
earlier; Roman rustic masonry appears above them; and over all is
lighter Saracenic work, with beautifully interlaced inscriptions. The
exterior walls are not much defaced, but the interior is one confused
mass of ruins.
The view from the top is wide and wonderfully
interesting. It embraces the whole southern slopes of the mountains,
which, though rocky, are covered from bottom to top with artificial
terraces, and fields divided by
stone fences. From their base the plain of
Bashan stretches out on the west to Hermon; the plain of
Moab
on the south, to the horizon; and the plain of Arabia on the east,
beyond the range of vision. For more than an hour I sat gazing on that
vast panorama. Wherever I turned my eyes towns and villages were seen.
Bozrah was there on its plain, twelve miles distant. The towers of
Beth-gamul were faintly visible far away on the horizon. In the vale
immediately to the south of Salcah are several deserted towns, whose
names I could not ascertain. Three miles off, in the same direction, is
a hill called Abd el-Maaz, with a large deserted town on its eastern
side. To the south-east an ancient road runs straight across the plain
far as the eye can see. About six miles along it, on the top of a hill,
is the deserted town of Maleh. On the section of the plain between
south and east I counted
fourteen towns, all of them, so far as I could see with my telescope, habitable like Salcah, but
entirely deserted! From this one spot I saw
upwards of thirty
deserted towns! Well might I exclaim with the prophet, as I sat on the
ruins of this great fortress, and looked over that mournful scene of
utter desolation, "
Moab is spoiled, and gone up out if her cities ... Moab is confounded; for it is broken down: howl and cry; tell ye it in Arnon that Moab is spoiled, and judgment is come upon the plain country ... Upon Kiriathaim, and upon Beth-gamul, and upon Beth-meon, and upon Kerioth, upon Bozrah, and upon all the cities of the land of Moab, far and near" (Jer. 48:15-24).
Another feature of the landscape impressed me
still more deeply. Not only is the country-plain and hill-side alike -
chequered with fenced fields, but groves of fig-trees are here and
there seen, and terraced vineyards still clothe the sides of some of
the hills. These are neglected and wild, but
not fruitless.
Mahmood told us that they produce great quantities of figs and grapes,
which are rifled year after year by the Bedawîn in their periodical
raids. How literal and how true have the words of Jeremiah become! "
O
vine if Sibmah, I will weep for thee with the weeping of Jazer: ... the
spoiler is fallen upon thy summer fruits, and upon thy vintage. And joy
and gladness is taken from the plentiful field, and from the land of Moab; and I have caused wine to fail from the wine-presses; none shall tread with shouting"
(Jer. 48:32, 33). Nowhere on earth is there such a melancholy example
of tyranny, rapacity, and misrule, as here. Fields, pastures,
vineyards, houses, villages, cities - all alike deserted and waste.
Even the few inhabitants that have hid themselves among the rocky
fastnesses and mountain defiles drag out a miserable existence,
oppressed by robbers of the desert on the one hand, and robbers of the
government on the other. It would seem as if the people of
Moab had heard the injunction of Jeremiah: "O ye that dwell in
Moab,
leave the cities and dwell in the rock, and be like the dove that maketh her nest in the side of the hole’s mouth."
And even thus they cannot escape, for "He that fleeth shall fall into
the pit; and he that getteth up out of the pit shall be taken in the
snare: for I will bring upon it, even upon
Moab, the year of their visitation, saith the Lord" (Jer. 48:28, 44).
*Modern
research in this, as in many other cases, has confirmed the accuracy of
Biblical topography. The Bozrah of Edom has been identified with the
village of Buseireh, among the mountains north of Petra; and here, in
the plain, we have the Bozrah of Moab. I was
somewhat surprised recently to find that the writer of the article
BOZRAH, in "Fairbairn’s Dictionary of the Bible," charges me with
holding the opinion of Kitto and others, that Bozrah of Edom, Bozrah of
Moab, and modern Busrah, are identical. I never held such an opinion. I have always affirmed, that Bozrah of Edom and Bozrah of Moab
were distinct cities; and had the writer of the article mentioned
turned to my "Five Years in Damascus," vol. 2 p. 160, or to my
"Handbook," or to the article BOZRAH in the last edition of "Kitto’s
Cyclopedia," he would have seen this.
**This opinion has been questioned by M. Rey, an accomplished French savant, who in the year 1858 retraced my footsteps through Bashan, and reviewed my "Five Years in Damascus"
as he went along. I had the pleasure of meeting M. Rey on several
occasions, and was impressed alike with his gentlemanly deportment and
accomplished scholarship; but being an intimate friend of M. De Saulcy,
whose pretended discoveries in and around Damascus I had criticized
perhaps a little too severely, I am not surprised that he should make
an occasional attempt at retaliation.